Comparison

View Paper
ESSAY DETAILS Words: 492
Pages: 2
(approximately 235 words/page)

Essay Database > Literature > English
Josh Manning Reader-Response Comparison William Faulknerís "A Rose for Emily" can have many different reader-responses, as any story can, however it is the responsibility of reader-response critics, like Robert Crosman, to determine if they are valid and helpful in understanding the story. "How Readers Make Meaning" is a failed attempt by Crosman to show that any reader response, no matter how far fetched, can be helpful in the interpretation of a story. Reader-response critics …

showed first 75 words of 492 total
Sign up for EssayTask and enjoy a huge collection of student essays, term papers and research papers. Improve your grade with our unique database!
showed last 75 words of 492 total
…the idea that the reader can comprehend the basics of a text. In Stacyís case she didnít get the basics of the text, in fact she didnít even realize that Emily had killed Homer Barron and slept with a his dead body for years. It is impossible to have a valid comparison of responses when the fundamentals of a text are not grasped and there lies the problem with Crosmanís argument.